The allegation that Matthew and Lukes accounts are contradictory is actually based on an assumption: the skeptic assumes that Matthew and Luke each included all of the whereabouts of Jesus family during His early life. It is widely understood that the likely time of Herod the Great death is sometime in 4 BC. Jesus, the Chief Shepherd of our souls, fasted 40 days and 40 nights before beginning his ministry. Later that night, Joseph had a frightening dream where an angel of God appeared to him. Jesus Christ stayed in Egypt for 1266 days which is 3 years and 5 months and some days. If this were true and Jesus did not observe these festivals during his stay in Egypt. His wife Samantha maintains this site as well as their missionary outreaches. Nicolas Poussin, The Holy Family in Egypt. Christianity is the second largest religion in Egypt. Could it be that Joseph, Mary, and Jesus returned to Galilee, to their own city, Nazareth (Luke 2:39) before going to Egypt, and then after traveling to and from Egypt they returned to Nazareth again (Matthew 2:23)? A book about stones in the life of Jesus can hardly ignore the Pyramids of Egypt. Why isnt the exact date recorded of Jesus birth? Jesus at the age of twelve accompanies Mary and Joseph, and a large group of their relatives and friends to Jerusalem on pilgrimage, according to the custom that is, Passover. If youre not yet familiar with the term and concept of recapitulation as used in Christian theology, you have some wonderful discoveries ahead of you. Jesus is born while they are in Bethlehem. When King Herod had died, Joseph could take his wife and child back to Nazareth from the exile in Egypt, where they fled to escape King Herod's order of killing all boys. Get up, he said, take the child and his mother and escape to Egypt. Herod died and was replaced by his son Archelaus in 4 BC. And since, according to the gospel of Luke, Jesus was born around the time of the first census that took place while Quirinius was governor of Syria, his birth occurred some time between 6 B.C. Any likely candidates? God in a dream, takes Mary and Jesus and goes down into Egypt. They remained there until the death of Herod. If Jesus is a Greek translation. Matthews gospel, which tells us about the Magi, also specifies that they followed the star from Jerusalem to the place where the child was, and that they went into a house to see him. I think this Christmas carol by Alfred Burt says it all. Joseph is 56 and Benjamin is about 40. Since Luke mentions nothing about Egypt, and Matthew says nothing about a trip to Nazareth soon after Jesus birth, allegedly either Matthew or Luke is mistaken. It is for the same reason we reject one another. NIV When they had gone, an angel of the Lord appeared to Joseph in a dream. and with thy heart as offering, Pyramids of Giza. Sign up for our free daily newsletter. Scripture tells of Joseph returning to Nazareth, avoiding any further residence in Judea. Simply because Matthew or Luke or any other Bible writer does not mention everything that every other Bible writer mentions about the same general time or event, does not mean that someone has erred. If it was to die so that our sins should be forgiven, why is there still going to be a Judgement Day, when those found wanting will be cast into the lake of fire and brimstone? Chris it seems odd to me that the most important thing that has ever happened on earth is not better documented. Speculative, but intriguing. Joseph and Mary did not actually flee to Egypt until two years after Jesus was born. And of course, we have four gospels which all more or less agree the details of his ministry for the last 3+ years of his life. I believe it also has to do with faith. Herod died in 4 B.C. That is, he gave it a fuller and deeper meaning in light of the significance of his own life. I cant help but laugh at the thought. They lived in Egypt, in a town called Fostat, near Heliopolis and not far from Cairo. In this blog, the author of the Understanding the Books of the Bible study guide series, the Rev. 1260 days is EXACTLY 3.5 years using the Jewish calendar of 360 days per year. Shepherds visit the baby and bow down in praise. Did Ruth seduce Boaz to get him to marry her? There were a few TV programmes about it. Matt. Thank you for visiting my blog Good Question. A reader has submitted this comment through the Ask a Question page on this blog: Verse 13. He was the sacrificial lamb. Our artists over the years have europeanised Jesus making him tall and pale with fair hair. Herod is going to search for the child to destroy him.". This was before news, media, and the web. Why were some books removed from the Bible and is it a sin to read them? How was he born 6 years before he was born?? Luke 1:57-80. Like this post? Tis love thats born tonight! They could easily have gone to Egypt . Well, for starters, as a rule in the ancient world births werent officially recorded as they are now, people didnt have birth certificates, etc. (Matthew 2:16-18). If Jesus family were in Egypt for much less than a year, why then does it say in the Revelation Prophecy of the Woman with 12 stars round her head, generally interpreted (incorrectly I believe) as Mary giving birth to Jesus, that she was transported to a place prepared for her for 1260 days, which equates to nearly 3 and a half years? Herod died in 4 B.C. You have obviously done some study on these issues. 2:13 says that they fled to Egypt after the Magi visited. Matt. May you be richly rewarded. He is 100% Middle Eastern and when we went to the beach this summer I was shocked at how white his (ordinarily) unexposed skin is. Then they continued traveling to Mostorod, a city north of Cairo. The Bible truly has answers to so many pending questions Glory be to God Almighty. He told the Thessalonians, for example, that Jesus died and rose again for us and that he rescues us from the coming wrath. But now, to help his friends stand firm in what theyve believed, Paul begins to spell out how Jesus life, death, and resurrection bring us salvation. At the age of about 30 , he d returned to the Middle East and the life that is familiar to us from the New Testament. Joseph is between 39 and 56 years old. If you were to go to MANY old European towns and visit their churches you would see statues and pictures if a Black Madona and child. In Luke 2:21 we read that the Lord was circumcised on the eighth day, but this didnt require them to go to the Temple. Most scholarship places the date of Herod's death around 4 BCE. Browse, sort & search all Bible Study resources. Download our eBooks to read on your computers, phone, tablet, or eReader. They were hiding from Herod, not from the Egyptians. You may want to look for further items of interest by using the resources below: the search bar; the lists of posts; and the list of categories. Was He dedicated at the Bethlehem temple? Go to REVELATIONS 12: 1 6. Joseph and Mary leave town without the 12-year-old Jesus, thinking him to be in another part of their caravan. There were two main roads to Egypt. Ehrman, Bart (2005),Misquoting Jesus: The Story Behind Who Changed the Bible and Why (San Francisco, CA: Harper). So the length of their sojourn in Egypt was probably about a few months. And he writes that if anyone is in Christ, the new creation has come. In other words, Jesus delivers us from the conditions that characterize the present evil age and enables us to live under the conditions that characterize the age to come or the new creation. how old was jesus when they fled to egypt. This has been a very good and interesting discussion, and the information you provided is informative, helpful, and much appreciated. So the Lord's birth, the visit by the Magi, the flight to Egypt and the return to Nazareth all had to take place between 6 and 4 BC. For anyone traveling in Egypt the Pyramids are hard to miss; Giza lies along the Nile River route that the Holy Family is believed to have followed. They made it into cakes, boiled it, and ground it into flour. But the gospel of Matthew primarily wants us to take away from this episode an appreciation for how Jesus recapitulated the history of Israel in his own life. There is a spring near the . Soon after the visit by the Magi, an angel appeared to Joseph in a dream telling him to flee to Egypt with Mary and the infant Jesus since King Herod would seek the child to kill him. Wells, Steve (2011), Skeptics Annotated Bible, http://www.skepticsannotatedbible.com/contra/egypt.html. We need to rely on the kind of research I report in this post. This passage identifies the place of Christ's birth as being Bethlehem of Judea and the time of His birth was . Herod orders the execution of all infant boys born in and near Bethlehem during the previous two years, so they flee by night right before the execution. It isnt that people want Jesus to be white. Why didnt God reveal the highest morality from thestart? 2- Joseph was still alive when Jesus was 12 . | Good Question, Egypt The Flight Into Egypt | Joseph Bias Ministries, Was Jesus ever in Egypt after being there as a child? Actually, when something in the life of Jesus recapitulates the history of Israel, the gospel writers usually give the specifics. But Matthew discreetly does not say where Jesus actually was when they arrived, just that the Magi followed the star from Jerusalem to that place. The Bible describes how an angel of the Lord appeared to Joseph giving him instructions to take Mary and the young child into Egypt (Matthew 2:13). I believe Jesus went to Egypt as a fulfillment t of prophecy. can u explain why joseph was not recognized by his brothers when they came here in egypt? It says simply that an angel of the Lord appeared to Joseph in a dream and warned him that the family needed to flee to Egypt because Jesus life was in danger from King Herod. All he had to do was to explain to us that we needed to repent and apologise for our sins, otherwise we would be killed. Good Question, Magi and Egypt Before Going Home | Katherine Speaks, https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/32953/why-use-bce-ce-instead-of-bc-ad, Did Joseph and Mary take Jesus to Egypt because they could blend in there? After 2,000 years of excavations no physical evidence of Jesus or any of his original 12 disciples has ever been found. Paul says here that Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law by becoming a curse for us. That is, Jesus substituted himself for us as the one under Gods curse for breaking the law. Three days later, realizing he is missing, they return and discover him in the Temple courtyard, where . Everyone CAN be forgiven if they choose to follow Jesus Christ. Beyond this, no one knew while Jesus was growing up that his life would turn out to be the most important thing that ever happened on earth. ESV Now when they had departed, behold, an angel of the Lord appeared to Joseph in a dream and said, "Rise, take the child and his mother, and flee to Egypt, and remain there until I tell you, for Herod is about to search for the child, to destroy him.". The term refers to how, as Gods redemptive plan unfolds and reaches its climax in the person and work of Christ, it can be discerned that the end looks like the beginning, although what happens in the end makes right whatever went wrong in the beginning. Reading the Bible for its true meaning requires that we understand it was written to the Jews using their culture and terminology. But, according to Galatians 1:17-18, Paul actually went to Arabia, back to Damascus, and then after three years he went up to Jerusalem. We have a better idea of when the sojourn in Egypt ended. All of these explanations capture some vital aspect of what Jesus does for us. According to Genesis 46:27, Joseph and his family numbered 70 people when they moved to Egypt. That is, he paid a price to buy us out of slavery, because we were enslaved to things that by nature are not gods. They make three points in support of their view: 1) Jesus was born when the star appeared; 2) Jesus is called a young child (KJV) in the wise men account (Matthew 2:8,9,11,13,14,20,21) and not a baby; and 3) the wise men found Jesus in a house (Matthew 2:11), not a stable or an inn. At your suggestion I have updated the image that accompanies this post. This is not including the mixed multitude that came out with them (Exodus 12:38) or the flocks and herds that they also brought out. So depending on when Jesus was born, the journey to Egypt lasted no more than two years, and perhaps as little as a few weeks or months. 2:19-23 says that Joseph Mary and Jesus returned from Egypt around that same time. It is argued that this example in Matt. So depending on when Jesus was born, the journey to Egypt lasted no more than two years, and perhaps as little as a few weeks or months. Jews originally were a brown people, you cant have zero melanin in a hot climate or desert climatic zones, would give you skin cancer. The Gospels were written after Jesus time and by people who never met Jesus. Jesus could just as easily, and far more logically, have arrived as a fully-grown adult on the day he presented himself to John for Baptism. Scholars dont believe the visit happened on the night of the Lords birth because Matt. Apologetics Press is a non-profit, tax-exempt organization dedicated to the defense of New Testament Christianity. How did the shepherds know where to find babyJesus? Here is my question, if the Magi began their journey at the birth of Jesus and it took 2 years to reach Him, and the visitation and giving of gifts took place in a manager, wouldnt that suppose that Jesus lived in a manger after His birth for 2 years? Matt. Alfred Plummer, in his exegetical commentary on the Gospel according to Matthew, notes that, We know neither how old the child Christ was when He was taken into Egypt nor how long he remained there. Those who choose not to believe, in this freely given eternal life, are only giving up the best thing ever!!! Some children see Him lily white, Listen to our Bible studies now from your browser. with skin of yellow hue. Jesus was born in Bethlehem of Judea. Good Question, Where did Jesus live in Egypt? Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. I read one article from (another website) stating that our Lord Jesus was probably 2 years old or at least near to that age when the Wise Men arrived. It was true that Herod died within a relatively short time, but his son still took over. But a year and a half seems too long anyway, at least as I figure it, as I explain in the post. . I hope this addresses your concern. It is only extremist groups such as the Taliban or ISIS, which hardly deserve the name Muslim or Islamic, that wantonly destroy historical records and artifacts. Jesus' childhood . I have never before seen it used as you have used it. How can believers in Jesus do even greater things than hedid? The episode is frequently shown in art, as the final episode of the Nativity of Jesus in art . Should a man desire to learn of them, let him ask for understanding. 1-43,44-49,50-53) and connected them with the Greek conjunction de (but or and), which has no specific chronological implications. He is whiter than me and I am of English/Irish/European descent. I think this article will help answer your question: https://www.gotquestions.org/Quirinius-census.html. The Gospel of Matthew, chapter 2, gives a biblical summary of Christ's early infancy and childhood. Jesus was born, and that is that! 14, note), and take the young Child and his mother, and flee into Egypt, and be thou . It is that he most likely WAS white based on the fact that he was an Israeli and most Israelis are white. So the gospels only record one trip to Egypt by Jesus, when he was an infant. It seems to me that the most likely scenario is that Jesus was born around 6 B.C., the wise men (by their own account) arrived in Jerusalem two years later in 4 B.C., and in that same year Joseph, Mary, and Jesus fled to Egypt, Herod died, and they returned. Moses was in the wilderness for 40 years, working as a shepherd, before God called him back to Egypt to deliver his people. book a tip slot neath how old was jesus when they fled to egypt The broad consensus of the community of Jesus followers was that this view did not faithfully represent Jesus, as his life and teachings were passed down from those who knew him. . The Church of St Sergius in Cairo stands where . He didnt change the Law, he fulfilled it. You can also download them to your computer, phone, or tablet. . He made it clear that him healing on the Sabbath was actually keeping it, as he was doing good, not bad. Including photos each week from our outreaches and the weekly review. There is no right way to god or mind power. He holds visiting professorship rank in five seminaries. I do not believe the comment is fair to Muslims, who, I find, have a profound respect for history and culture, even if it predates the founding of their religion. You say, And since Jesus was born around the time of the first census that took place while Quirinius was governor of Syria, his birth occurred some time between 6 B.C. Or that he is depicted to be white because white Europeans painted him that way. Matt. Mary was Blackthat makes Jesus Black. For example, its specified that Jesus spent 40 days in the wilderness, recapitulating Israels 40 years there, and that he chose 12 apostles, mirroring the 12 tribes of Israel. All my bibles says 1,260 days so l thought that was = to 4.59 years call it 4.6 if you will. Id read Heliopolis and surrounding towns as candidates, but Alexandria makes sense w/ the Jewish community there. You either believe the Bible or you dont. Scholars believe that he was born around b.c. How does the supposed census help us date the birth to Christ, and what historical records do we have to support this? How long did Jesus family stay in Egypt? What was is Jewish name? It is not true that the people of Israel are brown. Joseph, right after the Magi leave, is warned in a dream to flee to Egypt until Herod dies (Matthew 2:13 - 15). Neither writer made such a declaration (cf. Your Retirement News Channels. We could have easily understood that without him having to die! How about Islamic occupation of Jerusalem being the reason there are less records that we would hope. 2 + 3 = 5 before the death of Herod in Jericho at the end of March or beginning of April in 4 BC. Why can no one accept that the most logical and efficient way to have accomplished His mission to educate and prepare us, would be to arrive, carry out the mission and return to where he came from as soon as he was finished.This is exactly how his life on earth is recorded in Mark and John. Then in Session 19, about Galatians, I note that in this letter Paul gives several more illustrations of how Jesus life, death, and resurrection bring us salvation. He is predicted to return in the End Times and there is no suggestion in the scriptures that he is going to do so by being born of a woman then, so why should it have been any different when he came originally? And so Paul explains it in several ways: You could do research about these monestarys and churches in the Sina yourselves. Change). Matthew. In Jerusalem, at least 40 days after His birth, Jesus was dedicated at the . The Bible doesn't clearly state how old Joseph (the human father of Jesus) was when he died, but he was most likely aged 40-50 based on several factors: 1- Jewish men typically married once they were more financially secure, which implies that Joseph was around 20 years old when he married Mary. The best way to view our articles and Q&A. The 25 Stops of the Holy Family With Infant Jesus in Egypt. 1:18-25. There were about 1 million Jews living in Alexandria when Christ was born. How old was Jesus when his dad died? It was, however, no more than two years after Jesus was born, because Herod then tried to kill Jesus by slaying all of the baby boys who had been born in Bethlehem in the past two years, based on when the wise men told him they first saw the star. Later, after Herods death, Jesus family departed Egypt for Nazareth where they made their home (Matthew 2:19-23). . The Holy Family fled into Egypt, a land of the Gentiles, on February 17, 1 A.D. The Wise Men/Toddler Jesus crowd agree with Herod's conclusion. Coptic Christians believe the Holy familyJesus, Mary and Josephrested here in Wadi Natrun more than 2,000 years ago as they fled the persecution of King Herod shortly after Jesus was born . Matthew 2King James Version. 2:13 After they had gone, an angel of the Lord appeared to Joseph in a dream and said, "Get up, take the child and his mother and flee to Egypt, and stay there until I tell you, for Herod is going to look for the child to kill him." 2:14 Then he got up, took the child and his mother during the night, and went to Egypt. I will be looking it up. The flight to Egypt by Jesus family is related by Matthew to the statement in Hosea 11:1 which refers historically to the deliverance of the Hebrews from Egypt. The best chronologers have supposed that Herod died somewhere between two and four years after the birth of Christ, but the particular time cannot now be determined; nor can it be ascertained at what age Jesus was taken into Egypt. According to local traditions, the first stop for the Holy Family was Farma, east of the Nile river. Soon after the visit by the Magi, an angel appeared to Joseph in a dream telling him to flee to Egypt with Mary and the infant Jesus since King Herod would seek the child to kill him. So we dont know which angel this was. how old was jesus when they fled to egypt. Even among them at times is found compassion. The tree is still there after thousands of years in the middle off desert with nothing around it. He is the author of all the teachings here, and all materials are available free of charge! The fact is, however, such a conjecture cannot logically be upheld unless both of the inspired writers claimed to write exhaustive, chronological accounts of everything Jesus did. and, ah! Joseph with Mary and Jesus remains in Egypt till he hears through Matt. Tormented by a demon and on the run from a Roman centurion, a 7-year-old Jesus and his parents, Mary and Joseph, flee Egypt for Nazareth. Battle of Megiddo. View all posts by Christopher R Smith. Joseph immediately gathered his family together and left Bethlehem under cover of the darkness and stayed in Egypt until they . Rather, just as we oftentimes tell stories today and include certain details that others omit, so did the inspired writers of Scripture. Can you please explain further so that we can understand better? Matthew also includes the magi visiting Jesus and His family when Jesus was two years old or younger. As it was halfway through the lunar month, the night sky was lit by a full moon. I believe Jesus was born of a virgin, both man and God. I think it was closer to seven years. Where Christ as a child used his powers to bend the branch to give shade to his holy mother from the sun. But he came in a very different way for an important reasonto show us that whoever would be the greatest must be the least and the servant of all. When Jesus was 40 days old, Joseph . Luke 2:1-21. Receiving rich presents from mysterious eastern magi at Bethlehem after Jesus' birth, he then fled to Egypt to avoid the wrath . 8 AD approx. Credit: Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain. The Israelites set out towards Succoth (the ancient Egyptian town of Tjeku in the Wadi Tumilat). Why did God reject Saul as king for making one small mistake? and 4 B.C. Opening up another front against the atomization of the Scriptures: A review of the ESV ReadersBible, The Birth Of A King Part 21 | Joseph Bias Ministries, Did Joseph and Mary take Jesus to Egypt because they could blend in there, Which angel told Jesus parents to take him to Egypt? 4, some estimating up to bc. For the 430 years that Israel was in Egypt! His Apostles were fishermen and, most probably, illiterate. When Muslims capture a city like Jerusalem they destroy every bit of history documenting any civilization before them. Post author: Post published: February 17, 2022 Post category: sergei fedorov anna kournikova married Post comments: four characteristics of operations management four characteristics of operations management john aylward notre dame; randy newberg health problems There is no known age of Jesus after His Return from Egypt, but there are supporting facts that give hints. There they stayed until the already old Herod had died in 4 BCE. When they had finished the days, as they returned, the Boy Jesus lingered behind in Jerusalem. The final four verses of Luke 24 (vss. Unless the family went to Jerusalem for the festivals from Egypt during their sojourn there. What spiritual rejoicing was there when this little family, hides in the place that so long ago was used against Gods house. I am one. So when Mary and Joseph are running from another crazy ruler, where does God send them, well He has a great sense of humor, right back to the place that first tries to wipe out Christs family line in the beginning. The writer cited Luke and Mathew as a reference. The Holy Spirit certainly could have inspired Matthew to write his truthful account of some of the life of Christ without mentioning a brief return to Galilee. marmite benefits for hair. But in other cases a writer might use this notation to avoid just the type of confusion you pointed out, with Christ being born before Christ. I think we should assume up front that people have constructive motives unless they specifically express hostility. Thankyou. . There is a good documentary I saw years ago on PBS called Walking the Bible, made be an unbeliever I think, but none-the-less fascinating. A common knowledge among those who are familiar with the little facts provided in Scripture concerning Jesus' early life is that following the visit from the wise men, Matthew reports that Joseph and Mary took Jesus and fled to Egypt at the order of God (Matthew 2:13-14). We believe in the birth, life, death and resurrection of our Lord not because it is documented, but because of our faith. We grow food to support a community, build and repair homes, and support the poor, widows, and the fatherless. The Lord of heavn to earth come down. The calendar of BC and AD was adopted at a time when it was believed that Jesus had been born in 1 AD. Grace thru Faith is a 501(c)3 non-profit. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Return from Egypt Sometime after Herod had died, the holy family returns from Egypt . Much of this artwork was created BEFORE the sixth century. in Christs triumphal procession, portraying Jesus work as a victory over our spiritual enemies. Heres what I say in response to your questionWhat exactly was Jesus death all about?in my guide to Pauls Journey Letters. At this site the Church of Abi Serja, within the walls of the Fortress of Babylon, was built years later. Perhaps you were brought here by a search engine or by a link to one of the posts. Why must all questions, regardless to its relevance, lead to race? The Nativity and the Flight into Egypt took place in the last years before the death of Herod the Great which is known to have taken place in late March or early April, 4BC. 1 Timothy 5:18), omitted a part of someones life. two years old or . And see that the holy family spent close to seven years. Luke 1:39-56. You must accept that you are a sinner and you must accept that Jesus died so that your sins COULD be forgiven (if you have faith).